Strategies that Trade Earnings
Michael Nauss CMT (00:00)
Hello everyone, welcome to another episode of Line Your Own Pockets. ⁓ it's earnings season when we're recording this, so it's a pretty good time to talk about earnings and how to incorporate it into your trading strategies. And of course, knowing Dave, we're talking about the endless hours he spends on conference calls, listening to what CEOs say and whether or not their companies are good or not, right? That's what we're we're chatting about today.
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (00:25)
Yeah, that's exactly right. All that manual effort, all that ⁓ listening to conference calls, looking at reports. Yeah, if you know me, y you know that I don't do that.
Michael Nauss CMT (00:32)
Well, you know, there's people that do that. There's people whose job are to sit and listen to, which I never got because you're hearing the CEO and the CFO talk. What are they gonna do? Come on and say, Yeah, our company really sucks. Like this shit's going downhill hard. What you know, what are they gonna say? It's all the time everything's great and you know, any weakness in the numbers is temporary and blah blah blah blah and just spinning their own narrative every time.
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (00:57)
Yeah, yeah.
Yeah, so I think it's good that we take this on as a a systematic approach. And you bring up a good point that yeah, maybe not all traders think of this as ⁓ systematic in in in a way you could do it. And but but I know lots of traders, myself included, that have plenty of models that trade earnings. Purely systematically, no discretion at all. And there's just a lot of benefits to doing it.
Michael Nauss CMT (01:22)
Uh-huh.
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (01:31)
There's several, and we'll I'm sure we'll get into them. Probably the biggest thing though, it's like I hear traders all the time come to me and say, Hey Dave, I need I need an idea. Like I can't can't think of ideas for strategies. This is a really good one because it happens to every symbol. over the course of the the earning season. There's four earning seasons. ⁓ it's there's just so many advantages to doing it. And
Michael Nauss CMT (01:46)
Mm-hmm.
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (02:00)
It a lot of times the the I see traders that come up with strategies and I I would call them like the signal's not strong enough. I I I'll like to say it's the the signal's kind of soggy. Like, yeah, there's a signal there, but it it doesn't have a lot of oomph, right? So you end up optimizing that and you end up with it can work like that, but it's it's a lot easier when you have a signal with some oomph, right? So
Michael Nauss CMT (02:15)
Mm-hmm.
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (02:30)
Hey, earnings have umph. Everybody's looking at earnings, discretionary traders. everybody's looking at it.
Michael Nauss CMT (02:37)
Well, and that's that's I think the main thing is this ⁓ there's so many different ways to trade, right? D day trading and swing trading and investing and fundamental analysis and technical analysis and thematic stuff. And they all seem to culminate around this one date that you mentioned that happens. ⁓ rumors out there that they're gonna allow them to only do it twice a year. I don't know if that ever continued or if that died off, but I remember hearing that. But at least, let's say, right, twice to four times.
A year and like everyone has to do it. You can't be a publicly traded company and not report earnings. That's kind of the point. And yeah, it doesn't if you're a swing trader, you care. Because, you know, as we're recording this, like Google's the the third largest company in the world, it's down to like 15%. So if you're a swing trader, you care. If you're an investor, you care. If you're a fundamental guy, ⁓ you know, they've got you locked in a closet somewhere reading every page of of the document that came out.
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (03:10)
Mm-hmm.
Michael Nauss CMT (03:35)
And yeah, you get these moments where volume spiking, range is spiking, you know, options, whatever it is you trade, you you care. Even the guys who only trade futures, I think should still pay attention to like the pivotal earnings dates. Cause if you're trading just like the Nasdaq, well, you know, I think it's 30% of the Nasdaq is just a handful of companies. So if you pay attention during those particular earnings days.
On the same day, ⁓ you know, that that Google's now down, we have ⁓ as I look, the average stock is doing just fine. There's more stocks up than down today, but the Qs are down one and a half percent just because Google's down. So it doesn't matter, even if you're listening to this and you're only a futures person, well, having these events around these these large days, it's like it's like the whole time that the whole market kind of holds hands and gets together and say, Yes, this is something important that we should
be looking to take some sort of action off of.
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (04:35)
Yeah. I mean SB Capital likes to use the term catalyst a lot. And this is like one of the primary catalysts for discretionary traders, for systematic traders, you can be. So yeah, I think it's just incredibly important. ⁓ the other way I like to think about it is it's it's sort of like a news event, but the most important news event that happens on a regular basis. So
Michael Nauss CMT (04:41)
Mm-hmm.
Mm-hmm.
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (05:04)
In that sense, it's it's just so important. The other thing I like about it from a distress I mean a systematic standpoint.
There's a variety of ways you can incorporate this in your strategies, even if they don't quote unquote trade earnings. So you can not only have earnings be an event that you use a strategy to capture, like that's your signal. You could also use these as a universe. So you can include these the universe in your back test to see how it how you're sort of unrelated.
Michael Nauss CMT (05:35)
Mm-hmm.
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (05:43)
Strategy performs with earnings or without earnings. So there's just so many flexible ways you can use this in your data to make your strategies better, come up with ideas to trade creatively. So there there's just so much here that you should be thinking about. And and a lot of systematic traders don't think about it because there's only a few platforms that really allow you to use earnings in a back test in a pretty convenient way.
Michael Nauss CMT (06:13)
Yeah, I would say, you know, I feel like I'm like toting AI the whole time. But one thing I found that AI is really good at is backfilling that kind of data or information. So if you know, one thing that I do with Norgate data, it doesn't have the earnings date in it, but it is fairly straightforward to go through and just say, you know, find an external data source and just grab and huck them in. But you're right, that's extra work. And I don't think people do a lot of that work. And I think the
They generally default sometimes to just using gap as the proxy for earnings. But you can gap for ⁓ a lot of different reasons. And some some of them are going to be as impactful as earnings. I'm thinking like FDA events or, you know, new drug product releases or something like that. ⁓ but there is something very ⁓ specifically interesting to earnings from, you know, again, day trading standpoint, but not only a
That a swing trading standpoint, like one of the most studied phenomenons in market is the post-earnings drift, in where often you have an earnings event and then for days or weeks after there it can be a drift in that direction, while more and more participants that are generally slower to act, like large hedge funds that have investment committees and boring stuff like that, they start to kind of get on board as well. So yeah, regardless of time frame, I think.
Doing that extra work, even though it's not a default in a lot of ways, becomes like super important just to sit down and make sure that you're you're doing.
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (07:49)
Yeah.
Yeah, so I'm working with a trader now ⁓ who who wants to trade earnings. And he found a data source that I'd heard of before, but I hadn't looked into it. So he's going through this process now. He's using a a ⁓ data provider called Fin Model Prep. Terrible name. Terrible name, right? But
Michael Nauss CMT (08:11)
Okay. Yeah. Well, the massive guy kind of convinced us, didn't he? So maybe Finn?
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (08:20)
So you and he showed me the API for it. It's a really good, I mean it it it looks like a very good API where you can download all the historical data. ⁓ you get the dates, you get the, but but you also get importantly, the estimates and then the actuals for earnings per share and revenue, I think. So I think we should go into now how to use that in a back test.
⁓ and there's there's a couple different ways to do it, which I think are really pretty cool. And ⁓ but it's not when when traders gr try to go back test this, like they're using Amber Broker, they want to try to cram it in or shoehorn it in Amber Broker, but that's not the right way to do it. There there's ⁓ a better way to do it to get all the benefits from it without complicating your backtesting platform.
Michael Nauss CMT (09:17)
Well, and that's you're right, that's the biggest thing is because you know, getting that data kind of shoehorn in after it becomes when you're dealing with dates then it it becomes a little bit more complicated to to kinda line all of that up correctly. ⁓ I'm on this website, this Fit Market prep. So it'll be interesting to look at, but the the website's looking a little better than the name anyway. So I don't know, maybe we'll end up talking to this guy soon. So
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (09:43)
Yeah.
Michael Nauss CMT (09:46)
why don't you why don't you lead it off for for what it is first of all, I guess what is the in the data that you're trying to pull? Like date being the obvious thing, like when are they reporting data? I think is not only important for date, but also ⁓ before market or after market, or like a handful of brave souls that report during market hours, which I always say if I'm ever a CEO, I'm one of those guys. Like a random Tuesday at like 11:30, I'm reporting my earnings. There's like five companies, I think, that.
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (10:01)
Absolutely.
Michael Nauss CMT (10:15)
That have the guts to do it, but
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (10:15)
Yeah, a and and you'll have a whole bunch of traders ⁓ with giving you death threats. I mean that it's a terrible thing to have happen.
Michael Nauss CMT (10:24)
I'll just randomly. I'm not even gonna tell you. I don't know if they have to, but I'm gonna tell you the day. Boom, here's earnings. But that actually I, you know, leads so something I wanted to talk about when you're talking about how there's earning seasons. ⁓ and I I'm sure you've noticed this as well as kind of old market heads, they seem to be bleeding into each other more and more. I I I have noticed this where like NVIDIA reports so late.
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (10:30)
⁓ gosh. Please don't.
Michael Nauss CMT (10:50)
And then it seems like the next day the banks start to report. Like, ⁓ I just don't know if we're gonna get into a world where there's gonna be seasons more in the traditional sense, and it's just gonna be it's gonna be constant because that's the pushback that I think a lot of people have when they trade earnings. They say, Well, you know, there's on seasons and off seasons. And yeah, there is busy periods of time and then less busy periods of time, but throughout I think there's enough of a spattering where
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (11:14)
Yeah.
Michael Nauss CMT (11:18)
most days you're gonna get something, even if it's not like a large, like known company, but you're gonna get a handful of names that end up reporting. I just I think that's been a phenomenon that's exp like it's been smoothing out now for years where there's just more kind of spread throughout the the season.
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (11:35)
Yeah, interesting. So I did I went a did a deep dive on this a couple of years ago. And I have a ⁓ page on my website that shows the distribution over time. It shows the whole calendar year. And because you're right, you so this goes back to my stock ticker days where I was adding a filth basically a filter for in sea in earning season or out of earnings season. And at that point, sort of naive about it, I was like, Well, how do you
Michael Nauss CMT (11:46)
Mm-hmm.
Mm-hmm.
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (12:05)
Like it who who decides when earnings season starts and and finishes? Well, nobody, right? When you go down and look at it. And so it used to officially start, I think, when Alcoa released earnings. Like that was sort of the the understood day that okay, earnings starts on that day when they release it. But
Michael Nauss CMT (12:29)
I'm I I'm old enough to remember that, yeah.
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (12:33)
But when you look at the distribution of how many companies report over the course of the calendar year, it's there were a couple of very interesting things I've noticed. So when you plot the curve or the the the like do a a bar chart of the number of companies earnings, ⁓ reporting earnings on a given calendar day, they bunch up on the
Like the non-annual, so the one that starts in January is way more spread out than all the other quarters. So the other the all the other quarters, they're the bars are way taller, like they're there's the seasons are shorter, but they still like there's they trickle in, they shoot up big time, and then they trickle out. So the concept of a earning season like isn't really.
Like there's not a it's it's kind of silly to think of a specific date as when it starts and ends. ⁓ so but it but it was really ⁓ it was very enlightening to see this visualization of how companies report earnings over time. And now that you mentioned this, I'm gonna I wanna go back and revisit that to see what it looks like now compared to what it looked like before.
Michael Nauss CMT (13:30)
Mm-hmm.
I would expect it smoothed out more. And a lot of this was NVIDIA, where by the time no one cares about NVIDIA's earnings report really anymore. ⁓ because by the time they report, all of their clients have have already reported, which I think they did on purpose. So I think these guys have kind of pushed back the because they're gonna report like Microsoft and Google were today and they're not gonna report for like a month and just by
you know, spreading that out, you end up getting, yeah, the banks are the ones that started up now as opposed to Alcoa. And I think it's everybody is is kind of clamoring for their like moment in the sun. It's like a I want to report on times that no one else is reporting. ⁓ so I'm gonna either report early or late or on an off time or whatever. And that's just that's great for us because, you know, imagine a world in in the extremes where there was like a day that everybody reported. It's like, okay, well you have a bunch of trading to do that day. But that would
wouldn't be the best for us because you'd run out of buying power pretty quickly or or risk pretty quickly. ⁓ and in a world in where every day there's a handful of companies that report earnings, that's just gonna be better, it's gonna be more opportunity for us for for trading these systems.
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (15:01)
Yeah. It's ⁓ yeah, I think it's it's a good thing to look at. The the other so let's go back to well, let's talk a bit more about this the earnings season because I think that's an important distinction when you're creating a model to trade earnings. That makes it different because you have these cycles, you have these seasons where okay, there's ⁓ the earnings season's coming up, my s my strategy's gonna have signals during this.
season and then it's gonna stop. So that's unique and that you don't get that with most strategies that don't use earnings. You it's more of a random thing. So it gives you the opportunity, for better or worse, to like prepare for earnings during the off season and then you know it's coming and then you can wait for the season to go by and then evaluate that afterwards and you get this down period where you can do some research and figure out, okay, what am I gonna do next time? So that in that sense it it makes it really unique and
Michael Nauss CMT (15:38)
Mm-hmm.
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (15:59)
⁓ sort of a different cadence for this type of strategy compared to others.
Michael Nauss CMT (16:05)
Well, and that's ⁓ a lot of seasonal traders, and I know this won't be up your alley, but I always I buy and I read my stock traders almanac ⁓ every year. And all that is is a study of historical events like ⁓ you know, around tax and politics and things like this, generally, ⁓ what ends up happening with markets. It's one of I I think the earliest forms of systematic trading, because it's just looking and saying, Hey, you know, the after it seems to be
Around Christmas time, the markets seem to rip and they call it the Santa Claus rally. And here's kind of why. And here are things that we should look out for in order to potentially trade that profitably, not just take it because the day has come by and says that it should happen. And it's it's the same kind of thing where ⁓ having those kind of on and off moments can be great as as kickers is is more or less the way I look at Is you you generally want to have some strategies that just trade like every day. Just
based off of, you know, extreme moves or whatever that are happening. But I don't think there's anything wrong with having, you know, maybe call it like a a salary strategy that trades like, you know, mean reversion. It trades all the time and has a small edge and it just kind of repeats that edge. But then every now and then it's like you're mentioning, it's okay, it's game day, right? That you know, there's a ton of things are going, they're reporting earnings. Let's really, really make sure everything is is set up and dialed in and locked in. And I think that fits well with kind of the human psyche of
Right. You go really, really hard and then you you got your minute to to recoup and and and and and deal with. And that's why I think most people and and most I'd say prop firms and most people who get into trading are naturally gravitated on their own to n earnings, maybe not necessarily, but those large gappers and those big those big moves ⁓ after that. I think it's
yeah, it's a great place to start and it's a good kinda go hard, then take a take a rest and recoup and regroup and go hard again.
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (18:06)
Mm-hmm. Yeah, well, that's a good point too, because you know, think about traders and the trading lifestyle. If you're making, you know, a living trading, one of the questions you will eventually come across is what do I do for vacation? And because, you know, if you take vacation, you're not making money and you need to think about that. Do you want to go on vacation?
Michael Nauss CMT (18:24)
Mm-hmm.
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (18:36)
⁓ you know, during the most when there's a whole bunch of trading and your models do really well. No, you want to ideally you go on vacation and then nothing would happen, right? Or it would be happen to be a period where your model loses money, right? That's the perfect scenario, but of course of course it never works out that way. But yeah, you can use this as a way to schedule vacation during the off season. ⁓ and that's a a good way to think about it. I mean, some portion of my strategies have an earnings component, so
Michael Nauss CMT (18:43)
Mm-hmm.
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (19:06)
⁓ that's something I think about when I try to figure out, okay, when am I gonna go on this trip that where I'm not gonna be trading? ⁓ I I would definitely consider that.
Michael Nauss CMT (19:17)
I I've got a I've got a trader buddy who ⁓ he's a swing trader as well and he has kind of a standing thing with the wife that if the VIX is too high, he's allowed to cancel he's allowed to cancel like things that are going. So he's gone on a lot of vacations recently because the market's been incredibly you know range bound and boring for months. But he has that as like, you know, she's like, okay, we're going, and I'm he's like, dude, the VIX just spiked to
To 30, I I have to, I I can't. We we've got to push back the vacation. Yeah, and it's the same thing. It's just saying there are times where ⁓ for him in his trading style, he knows that his models and systems are are really going to do well or and generally do much better in these higher volatility type environments. And you know, sometimes that just happens randomly when there's a trade war or something that breaks out and ⁓ then the market ends up.
really moving. So it it is important to understand that. And that's f one of I think the primary benefits of systematic trading is that A, you can trade so many systems that hopefully you're always able to find something, you know, down the road eventually. ⁓ but B, you're able to have something that naturally, you know, turns on the gas and turns on the brakes, depending on whether or not there's a lot going on.
And I think that's really hard for human beings to do discretionarily to sit down and just say, today is not a good day to be trading. And because they're constantly out there looking for something to do. And when you're out there hunting, you're you're kind of pointing your brain at I have to take a trade. Whereas sometimes I look down, I'm I'm in like 10, 15 trades, and I know that's a pretty busy day. And then sometimes I look down, I'm like two or three.
So it's just naturally on its own kind of ebb and flowing based off volatility of the market and based off whether or not your system finds edge or not.
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (21:10)
Yeah. So let's go back to the data providers for this and the platforms and how different ones support earnings or don't support earnings. So most of the data feeds you provide that are provided like massive ⁓ IQ feed. When you get a bar data feed, it's not gonna have earnings in it. So you're gonna have to get it from somewhere else. ⁓ so we mentioned the fin model prep and
You can always tell when a company has actual traders there or have or collaborate with actual traders because and I can tell that well, at least the way FinModel Prep has set their data feed up is not how a trader would do it. Because it has the date reported in there. So what you have to do, so the the most important thing about earnings.
From my perspective, is earnings that were reported before the open today is basically equivalent to the earnings that were reported yesterday after the close. Because today is the first market session after they reported. Well, if you if you report yesterday after the close, that's going to be a different date than today before the close. But they're functionally equivalent. ⁓
Michael Nauss CMT (22:22)
Mm-hmm.
Mm-hmm. Yeah, because you haven't gotten the day that the and the the important thing I guess for for listeners that institutions like large traders, they're not they're not buying the the second after. You know, you'll have some quant systems or whatever run, but that market open is still very important because that's where the liquidity is and that's where the big boys start to start to play. So it doesn't matter what the calendar was at the time that you report is the batteries have
Have the big guys had their day to react to whatever's happened and then yes or no and then, you know, take the trade. ⁓ take the trade then. So yeah, I would I would totally agree with that.
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (23:16)
So some platforms support that really well, others don't. Like Trade Ideas does a really good job at this because there's a very specific filter that you can find in Trade Ideas for earnings date. And the way that works is there's it's it's it's a numeric value relative to today. So what that allows you to do is set up an alert window or a top list that has today's earnings.
Michael Nauss CMT (23:23)
Mm-hmm.
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (23:47)
like an earnings alert for all companies that have reported either this morning before the close before the open or yesterday after the close. And then each day that goes by automatically includes that. So it automatically updates. I've got ⁓ I'm if you go to my website, I'm I'm offering all my trade ideas windows. There's for free. If you go to the free tools section, this this one's included.
Michael Nauss CMT (24:04)
Mm-hmm.
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (24:13)
It also has the ones that are upcoming. So tomorrow's. So you can look at both of these windows and see: okay, here's the ones reporting for today. Here's the ones reporting for tomorrow. And on any given day, they update. So you don't have to make any settings change to see the list. And this is this is another such an important thing to be able to do is as you you want to put yourself in a position to notice the unusual things. So this is these are.
Windows I use at the end of the day to do chart reviews to see, okay, what did my models take? What did I what big moves did I miss? And brainstorm how I can get in, how I can create a strategy to to to get coverage of some of these moves where I might not have it now.
Michael Nauss CMT (24:50)
Mm-hmm.
Yeah, and I that's, you know, a little off topic, but I think should be should be touched on too is those chart reviews where ⁓ and no, we we well we can tie it in just by saying, hey, if you just want to look at what you should be doing, 'cause that could be the the next question is okay, well, you know, I get this date in, but what should I be doing around earnings? But I like what Dave does and you know, even after doing it for so long, still has a little bit of time carved out, shouldn't take too long.
To go through and just say, you know, these are the companies that reported earnings and here's what they did. And I'd say that's the best kind of launching off point is you could just even before you spend money on the data and before you end up going through, you know, if you want it, if someone's listening to this and they're just like, I want an exercise to do, is just go and grab, ask Claude, okay, tell me everything that reported earnings last night and everything that reported earnings this morning, and just have a list and just go through the charts, like every day. And it should take you.
Some days five minutes, maybe. You might go through what would the daily chart look like, what you know the intraday chart look like, and just kind of put yourself in that observer kind of mindset and just go, well, is there anything that I and then as you start to notice things over and over again, then you go, okay, well now I have something to test, and maybe you're onto something, maybe you're not. who who knows? But yeah, I think that's super important. And I get that all the time is where to come up with ideas.
We we talk about all the time because we've been doing this for so long that we have almost an infinite of amount of ideas that we want to test. So that's generally not the problem for us, but it is the problem, I think, for people who are starting. And I think that's the way to solve it is just sit down, you know, tab through 2030 charts. You could even, if you want to be real lazy, I guess you could probably get go claude if you have the like an IQ date fee data source or something.
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (26:40)
Mm-hmm.
Michael Nauss CMT (26:49)
Say I want you to do it and just send me a PDF that I'm gonna sit on the couch every night with an iPad and flip through the PDF of here's what, ⁓ all the things at reported earnings and and whatever. I just think it's a it's a great place to get started.
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (27:03)
Yeah, and that and that was why I released all my ⁓ windows. So there's there's like eight or ten windows I have that I do this exact thing for. So you can go to my website and and get the trade ideas windows. Like there's everything there about them. So it's a good place because people are especially new traders, are starving for ideas. And this is you have to put in a process to put yourself in a position on a regular basis.
To notice the unusual things. And that's what we're talking about. And that's why I created that chart review. with all my trade ideas windows in there. All right. So once you sort of no what I would call loosely normalize the date in your data feed to get it to figure out, okay, today you know what symbols reported today, what you know, whether it was last night or this morning.
What can you do with that? Well, the first thing you could do is create like create a universe for a strategy. And only you so when you say tr only trade earnings, the this is the exact universe we're talking about. They've reported before the open today or yesterday after the close. Now there can be there can be a go ahead.
Michael Nauss CMT (28:21)
Now you know, sorry to interrupt, but do you do you ever go back and just split those just to see if there's a difference? 'Cause okay, 'cause I I just I don't think I have, and I'm like you know, I've always had the same assumption you are, and I'm like at some point I should just go back and just you know, split up and see if there's anything. Hmm.
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (28:29)
I was I was just gonna ready to say. So
So some platforms like Trade Ideas, like other platforms, will let you query on did it report you know and separate them. Look show me the ones that reported before the open, show me the ones that reported yesterday after close. I've always f for the most part, I've always looked at those as equivalent, like you said.
Michael Nauss CMT (28:59)
Mm-hmm.
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (29:07)
But yeah, there is, it's a it's an easy way to create a different universe for ones that reported yesterday, once it reported this morning. And yeah, you can always throw that in a column in your library and see if there's a difference there. and yeah, it it will sometimes you will see some differences like the move happened yesterday ⁓ after the close, and you know, it's it's sort of calmed down today, and there is some difference. So so in some sense, you it's
Michael Nauss CMT (29:19)
Mm.
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (29:35)
The move is older and ⁓ the one that happened the night the night before. So in the you know, you you could come up with a story about how ⁓ or a theory about how that could make a difference in in what you're doing. And and it's easy to look at when you have the data in that way.
Michael Nauss CMT (29:53)
Yeah, 'cause I was just thinking, you know, even though the the big guys haven't had their chance at the pie, you know, something that reported at four PM the day before versus, you know, ⁓ nine PM right before the market opened, it is staler, right? It has is it it has had s more time, I guess, to digest. They've had time to sleep on it or something like that. ⁓ yeah, just it's again, this is the beauty of
doing this stuff is cause when you're putting it out there, I'm like, just I haven't gone. Maybe I did initially, ⁓ but now I have way more data and all that kind of stuff. Maybe I should go back and take a look at some of these and see if there is a there is a split that matters a little bit more. So ⁓ when you're doing them in the in your you're putting the data in and and you're normalizing it. Are you doing it just the way trade ideas does, which I think is like what zero is the open of
What zero is the open of the earnings day and then it's like negative one, negative two, positive one, positive two. Is that how that
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (30:58)
Correct. Yeah, and it does fractions. It's I always forget exactly the rules and have to go back and look, but but if you ⁓ the chart review on my website that has those windows in there, it's all configured so you don't have to go through and figure it out. It's all configured right there. But yeah, it's ⁓ that that's how you do it. And it's it's it's a convenient way. It's I mean I it is the right way as far as I can tell. I can't think of a better way to do it than that. That seems pr that seems quite quite good.
Michael Nauss CMT (31:03)
Mm-hmm.
Mm.
Yeah, and I guess for listeners who've never used trade ideas, essentially w ⁓ what they've done is they've normalized so the open of the reporting day. So any any right, the the current day is zero. And if earnings happened, say negative one, again we don't remember the fraction, but negative one, that would be the morning before. And then like negative two would have been the night before. And so you're always just anchoring.
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (31:50)
Actually it's y it's the right spirit. It's not exactly right, but so negative one would be yesterday, negative two would be the two days ago, and then there's fractions that show like before the open today, yesterday after and close. Yeah.
Michael Nauss CMT (31:54)
Yeah.
Okay. So negative ha point five percent. So yeah, they're splitting up each section into ⁓ into a nor numeric value. And this just might happen you this might help people who are trying to do the that nitty gritty work. And it would be the same thing of saying, ⁓ you know, looking out into the future and saying, okay, this one has earnings tonight or tomorrow morning. because I could see a world, I don't do it any I don't do it currently, where you could be trying to avoid
You know, maybe your your theory is that stocks don't move the day before earnings because people are waiting for for that bet to kind of come in. And by by picking, you know, one day and saying this is kind of my zero day, and here's you know, me splitting up the market on this side, and here's me splitting up the market on that side, that makes it so that you should be able to very simply, when it's time to grab the days, you're grabbing the days that are in some sort of numeric band and saying, Okay, show me everything that's a a
a one or a two or a negative one or a negative two and I'll know kind of where things things exist as opposed to dealing with dates and then trying to to kind of mess around that way. That that normalizing at zero I I do think is the the best way that I've never thought thought of a better way when playing with it. So
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (33:05)
Yeah.
Yeah. Yeah. And if you've ever done any programming for any length of time, you realize just how complicated it is to deal with dates, especially when you're especially when you have users in different time zones, different parts of the world. It gets complicated way fast. It seems like, there should be a library for this, but it's way harder than you think it is. So yeah, I love I love the way this is ⁓ so elegant the way the way trade ideas does it. I love that. ⁓ all right, so
Michael Nauss CMT (33:21)
Mm-hmm.
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (33:41)
What that allows you to do set up a universe for like different things that we're talking about. And that could be an input to your strategy. So the way I like to think about strategies is you have universes like this, so a set of ⁓ a universe for the strategy, and then entry tactics. What entry tactic are you gonna use for this universe? I think it's really good to separate them that way. It's like breaks it down into bite-sized pieces to to create a strategy.
⁓ I think that's ⁓ I think that's really useful for systematic traders to think about it that way. You might have multiple entry tactics for an earnings universe. Like you may have multiple different ways to enter for that. So one of the entry tactics is like we've alluded to earlier, enter on the open. That's certainly a valid entry tactic and ones that a lot of traders use, and a lot of traders use ⁓
Michael Nauss CMT (34:33)
Mm-hmm.
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (34:40)
for exactly this scenario, trading earnings and getting in right on the open.
Michael Nauss CMT (34:46)
Yeah, and that ⁓ we've talked with this before, but that simplifies a lot of things when it comes to slippage and and all of this. If you're using like an actual legitimate market on open order, you know that you're getting the same fill that everyone else is getting, right? If there's enough volume, you you know exactly ⁓ what you're getting. It just like if you were to put out a limit order. It either, you know, gets there or or it doesn't. And but with market on open orders, you are just getting whatever that opening print is.
Then you can go from there and and you can kind of expand out. And I you know, I like that you mentioned that because I was going to too. The the difference between looking at ⁓ the difference between ha not just having one strategy, because I w I think a lot of people may have been thinking as we were talking, there is an earning strategy. It's like, no, there could be could be an infinite amount. There's like
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (35:38)
Yeah.
Many. Yes.
Michael Nauss CMT (35:42)
You know, opening range breaks on earnings, there's mean reversion after earnings, there's, you know, maybe something before earnings, there's all kinds of different ways that you can play it. So ⁓ you know, just because we may be using some things as examples, just think that this is just alternative data. You could you could look at it that way, right? You're applying alternative data and not even building a new strategy. If you're someone out there who has existing strategies, ⁓ this just seems like a good project to do.
Just to add to your existing, whether it's day trading or swing trading or whatever, you could just build a a filter that says, you know, proximity to earnings before or after, and just run that through your same model. And maybe you found a scenario in which you are incidentally trading earnings sometimes. And you know, having that filter in and filtering things out of that could make your system way better just by having this new data set that you just really haven't.
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (36:32)
Yeah.
Michael Nauss CMT (36:41)
Haven't played around with before.
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (36:43)
Yeah, it's funny you mentioned that 'cause I was recently on the Be the Trader podcast where I went over the detailed rules of one of my systems. And that system is one that earnings has a big effect on. And yeah, I I learned that from like I traded this strategy forever and with with ignoring earnings. And then once I applied earnings to it, I like, Wow, okay. Yeah, that does make a difference. It's it's like ⁓
Michael Nauss CMT (36:53)
Mm-hmm.
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (37:12)
And that's where it made it made it really clear that it's just a it's just a very powerful news item, is is how I think of earnings.
Michael Nauss CMT (37:22)
So that strategy, was it when it wasn't doing earnings, was it just using gap as a proxy? Is that what you were you were trading gaps before and then you realize that, you know, gaps because of earnings are more impactful than gaps because of analyst upgrades or something like that?
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (37:29)
Yeah.
Yeah, like the reason for the gap. Yeah.
Michael Nauss CMT (37:43)
Yeah. Yeah. And that's cause I I I I asked because I found the same thing too. I had a gap strategy and then it's like, okay, not all gaps are created equal. Earnings gaps did well. ⁓ FDA gaps on the random sampling that I did, 'cause it that finding that data is hard as well, did well. But then gaps just because, you know, they positive mention on Kramer the night before or something like who cares about that. Those were more likely to fade, which ends up
Just like everything we talk about in systematic trading creates another branch to look at, right? Maybe, you know, th you do something with the earnings gaps and you do something completely opposite with the non-earnings gaps, and you've created two systems just because you have this data now.
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (38:27)
Yeah, and and the first thing you should do with it is add it to your column library. It's it's it's a simple zero or one. Is this an earnings play today on this on the the given day? So yeah, having that as a column in your library is great because it'll automatically show up. You know, the cruncher will find it if it's important. And you can also use the filtering to say, Okay, only show me earnings names for this strategy.
And then crunch it that way. So yeah, there's ⁓ there there's just a lot of flexibility, more than you realize when you just naively talk about earnings and and you have some picture in your head. ⁓ all right, you ready to talk about a new idea that around earnings that I haven't tested yet, but I think is I'm working with one of these traders to ⁓ to do it.
Michael Nauss CMT (39:19)
Sure. I'm I'm you've you've got me got me peaked up. But now is this gonna be you're looking at the ⁓ Ibida and then you're making your decision based off of off of that or
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (39:22)
⁓
No, no, it's it's even simpler than that. So back to the fin model prep data and the API. And I mentioned one of the things they have in there is the estimates for EPS and then the actuals. So what the estimate was before they released earnings and then what the actual number was when they released it. So there's some really interesting things you can do with this. So one of the things you could do is
Michael Nauss CMT (39:47)
Mm-hmm.
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (39:58)
Set up a universe for earnings beats or earnings misses.
Michael Nauss CMT (40:04)
And by a certain certain threshold, which is where my brain went instantly. Guys who really whiff it or guys who really knock it out of the park.
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (40:07)
And by a certain threshold, yes.
Yeah, so it's got the numbers in there where you can do that computation. My guess is that
I would think you'd need to look pretty hard at the data because I'm assuming there's gonna be some big outliers in there and you'll need to look and and and figure out how to deal with those. But yeah, I think you could ⁓ quantify really big misses or really big beats and separate those from just slight beats or slight misses. But yeah, there's lots of different ways to use that. And yeah, I've got there's a trader I work with at SMB that does has strategies.
Michael Nauss CMT (40:28)
Mm-hmm.
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (40:50)
just for earnings beats, just for earnings misses. But I don't believe he's ⁓ I I've never I've not looked at the data myself. I I've not done that, you know, quantifying the level of the miss or the l the level the beat. That would be interesting. And you could easily set up a a column in your library for that.
Michael Nauss CMT (41:07)
Yeah, that's
Well and it's funny, I was actually gonna ask you that specific thing about the data, because back when you you know, right the beginning of the podcast when you mentioned that, that was gonna be my my question because I would guess, and we're just guessing, so we we could be way off base air, I would guess that that would be even more impactful than the earnings itself, right? If earnings comes out exactly in line the way ⁓ you know, the company estimated three months ago, it's like, okay, fine.
Right. But I'd assume ⁓ you know, something that came out just wildly unexpected would create way more potential volatility and way more potential trading signals because there's just so many people who have to kind of completely remodel what they think of the company, right? If it's like especially if it's ⁓ man, so I ⁓ so we should have got an affiliate link or something for these guys because I'm gonna go buy them. I'm interested here because I all kinds of
ideas are coming into my head, and this is the cool thing of when you incorporate any new data source as well, is you just open up like a couple months worth of work for you. Cause I'm thinking like, what about ⁓ binary flips where the company was expected to be negative EPS and they're positive EPS, right? Like so, you know, that's a money losing company to a money making company, things like this. ⁓
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (42:25)
Uh-huh.
Michael Nauss CMT (42:33)
In a very simple way for people out there who are very into fundamental analysis and have been looking for a way to quantify it, well, I think this is kind of the ground floor of it. Because they're binary events, therefore they are much easier to build in and to program and and to deal with because it's either right they reported earnings they didn't, they beat earnings or they didn't, they you have a benchmark and then a a something to go against the benchmark.
And like we talk about, these are gonna be the days that everybody perks up and takes notice and is interested in what's happening.
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (43:04)
Yeah. Yeah, I think there's just there's just lots of ways to do it. The other so I wanna close with this last topic around earnings that I think is overlooked, or if any, I I've never heard anybody say it, but I think it's a really valuable opportunity for systematic traders. And here's what I mean. Think about earnings and how much attention they get. Discretionary traders sometimes
This is all they're looking at. That it's 100% is going to be on their radar. Really good discretionary traders who don't systematically trade. And what I always, you know, when I work with a trader, one of the things I always help them with is figuring out how to reach out to people to have good collaborations and figure out what their trusted trader group is going to be and how they can continue to think about that going forward.
Michael Nauss CMT (43:38)
Mm-hmm.
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (44:04)
Earnings is a really good way to ⁓ strike up conversations, offer help to discretionary traders who are already very familiar with this universe in their world, and marry systematic trading. So there's some really good collaborations you can do like by just watching discretionary traders trade earnings and how they think about it. And that can be a starting point for a collaboration with.
s discretionary and systematic traders in a way that's really productive.
Michael Nauss CMT (44:39)
Mm-hmm. Yeah, you could just say, Hey, I looked at the data and I noticed this weird thing. Have you thought about that? And send them off with that. And ⁓ you know, they'll they'll come back if if you're right, they'll come back very grateful, hopefully, saying, Hey, you know, you should look at this one one part of it, because when you're dealing with this kind of binary stuff, it's very it's easier to say, ⁓ hey, there's just this one potential little tweak, and that one lit potential little tweak can can equal a lot of money.
Just by, I don't know, for example, the earnings beats versus mess that we just talked about. If you find something in that data and you share that with someone, ⁓ and you're just filtering out bad trades that they would have taken, people will be really grateful for that.
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (45:21)
Yeah, and I think, you know, discretionary traders sometimes look at systematic traders as like aliens or like they just don't talk the same language. Where this this is this can be Arne's can be a bridge for that. And it can be a common thing that you know both know about from different angles, and that could be a good basis for a collaborative strategy you work on together.
Michael Nauss CMT (45:32)
Mm-hmm.
Mm-hmm. Yeah, and those are usually the most interesting ones where you've got we've got the whole trusted trader group, which I think last year we ranked as the highest or one of the highest episodes. So definitely make sure you're you're checking that one out where you're ⁓ you know, ⁓ different points of view and just talking with traders. Like I actually have I've got an Apple Notes thing open here that I've added like three things during this podcast.
to talk about and you never know when they're gonna come from. You know, I don't I that's doesn't happen certainly every podcast, but ⁓ you know, there's a couple of things that I'm like, I should go back and look at that, or that's an interesting thing that maybe I wanna I wanna take a look at. And it's one of the best ways to get it is just find people ⁓ that you can chat back and forth with and like Dave mentioned, everybody. Doesn't matter if the guy's a investor or
Or swing trader, day trader, whatever, they're they're gonna care about earnings. They they have to. They it's you know, it's like the politics and taxes when I was talking about the seasonality stuff. There you can't avoid it. You can ignore it, but y you can't avoid it.
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (46:53)
Yeah. All right, so yeah, I think we covered ⁓ covered a good bit here, more than I thought we were with earnings. ⁓ I we've probably got a lot of links to put in the show notes. I know I I'll I'll try to find the that bar graph I talked about for the season. I think that's a really good visualization. I'll try to put that in the show notes. Yeah.
Michael Nauss CMT (46:59)
Mm-hmm.
Yeah, let me know when you redo that. I'll be interested to see the changes. Cause I think I remember now you doing that years and years and years ago. So it'll be interesting to see how it's changed with the with the new data. ⁓ and as always, you know, if you guys find any cool strategies you want to share in the comments, we'll we always read them and ⁓ and and definitely like hearing if we've helped you out at all in in kind of your hunt here for finding good trading strategies. But as always, I'm Michael Noss.
Dave Mabe, MabeKit (47:19)
Yeah, I'm curious now too.
And I'm Dave Mayb. Talk to you next week on Line Your Own Pockets.
Creators and Guests